Skip to main content

Beautiful Questions

Recently I finished a book called A More Beautiful Question by Warren Berger. A speaker at a conference this year recommended it, and the title intrigued me. As the name suggests, the focus is on how quality questions generally drive the best businesses to true success. Asking the right questions is an essential aspect to strong leadership. Beyond thinking about leadership in the business world, the notion of quality questioning can be applied to one’s personal life but also about schools and education. In fact, the book makes a case that our education system generally rewards answers from students, even though the evidence suggests that being able to ask the right question is an essential skill in the workplace. Not unlike Ken Robinson, who maintains that our educational system intentionally educates creativity out of children, Berger maintains we do the same for curiosity and questioning. He highlights that human questioning hits its peak at about four years old, where research shows kids can ask over 300 questions a day – a data point I can validate from research in my own house.
I decided to put all of this to test in my Ethics class this week. This happened to be the class where we wrestled with the moral dilemma of balancing the needs of the individual with the needs of the community. I often ask students to consider the ethics of torture in this context, exploring some of the context around Guantanamo Bay and other case studies from history. But this year I tried a method suggested by the book. I split the kids into groups and put the statement “Torture can be ethically justified” on the board and gave them fifteen minutes to brainstorm any question they could think of in relation to that statement. Eventually I had them refine open-ended questions into closed questions and then guided them to rewrite some starting with “How might we” as in “How might we understand…“ or “How might we know...” Finally, I asked them to isolate the three best questions their group had created. Here are a few examples:
  • How might someone’s identity change how they are tortured or treated?
  • How might we justify things we know are not right?
  • Is torture simply a form of revenge?
  • Who decides if torture is justified?
  • What kinds of punishments should be considered torture?
Finally, we reflected a bit on the experience and upon what they thought made a good question. We concluded that a great question makes one consider a problem in a new way. We also thought it was different for the emphasis be on asking rather than solving. Finally, we realized that we are not often asked to refine questions and think about their quality – usually we just spit them out.

I think there is a connection here to Curriculum 2020 and student directed learning. While good questions have always had value, I suspect companies are looking for provocative thinkers more so than content producers. All of this has led me to my own more beautiful question: How might we teach the skills of questioning more thoughtfully at Berwick?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A Final Dance

The Berwick events are jam packed in these final weeks of May, but a particularly special one for me has always been the amazing dance shows. Each year I am inspired to see how this program – a school within a school – comes together to put on such extravaganzas for the community to enjoy. Last weekend’s edition was one of my favorite moments to truly soak in the nature of a PK-12 school, as one can’t help but notice the progression of talent and development throughout the dance companies. Perhaps even more impressively, the dance program is one of the greatest examples we have of mentoring and role modeling across divisions. Whether that is as impressive as shared performances on stage or as mundane as managing the littlest dancers backstage, it is truly a community effort. Selfishly, this is the one program on campus that all three of the Schneider girls love equally, and as a parent it has been such a gift to see them on stage together. While they share a common bond through the
Post a Comment
Read more

E.T.

I don’t think everyone is aware that for this period between Thanksgiving and Winter break, grade levels within the Middle School temporarily re-organize themselves to offer interdisciplinary learning experiences to break up the regular routine of class. This year, I was asked to participate in the “Machine Pilot” aspect of the seventh grade effort to explore the concept of extra-terrestrial life (E.T.). Seventh graders are asked to consider who, out of anyone on the planet, they would choose to send into outer space to interact with alien life forms and why. Our students are told they can literally choose any person on the planet, and the focus need not necessarily be someone with experience in space travel. In fact, they are asked to envision a pre-programmed ship with one seat, leaving them to consider not just technical skills but who would we want to represent human kind in this first interaction. They research, create resumes, write persuasive cover letters and are ultimately as
Post a Comment
Read more

The Campus as Mission

Yesterday, I was fortunate to spend an entire day with our board in retreat to discuss the future of Berwick Academy. The day included strategic conversations about the future of financial aid, innovation, and our amazing campus. In considering the strengths of the Berwick campus, almost everyone spoke to the remarkable quality of our main quad, the blend of old and new buildings, and the incredible open space we have to support our programs. There is an aura of learning and support on this campus that is clearly bolstered by the physical space and buildings. This sense will only be strengthened by the addition of the new Wellness Center next year. Looking ahead, there are still improvements to be made. Certainly parking is a concern, and we continue to dream about new facilities that might make the Berwick experience even more special for our students. One of the key insights that emerged from these conversations was the way in which the physical campus needs to reflect the
Post a Comment
Read more